Safeguarding Creativity - A Deep Dive into IPRs

Intellectual Property (IP) refers to creations of the mind, such as inventions, literary and artistic works, drawing, painting, piece of art, designs, symbols, musical compositions, plant varieties etc which are protected by law. These rights grant the creator exclusive rights to use, exploit and commercialize their creations for a specific period.

Real property is corporeal property. Whether moveable or immoveable, it is physical, tangible and visible. Incorporeal property, also called as intellectual property is intangible if not invisible, yet it exists and gets manifested. Physical that is real property refers to any personal property that people earn or create and own. Law confers legal rights on individuals and entities to own their personal properties and protect them. Like real property, intellectual property is also a personal property protected by law.

As the name suggests, the term ‘intellectual property’ is the creation of intellect, i.e., the human mind. Various efforts in terms of inputs of manpower, time, energy, skill, money, etc., are required to create or invent something new. It starts with an “idea” and relates to creativity and invention. Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) are territorial rights. Inherent in the notion of territorial rights is the idea of exercising control over a geographically bounded area of land. These rights can be registered with an authority in some presentable or tangible form which can be sold or bought or licensed, similar to physical property. These rights provide a secure environment for inventors, scientists, artists, designers, traders, farmers etc. to foster innovation and scientific temper. Rights like ‘right to privacy’ and ‘right to publicity’ are given to creator or innovator to harvest the economic benefits on their creation or invention.

Intellectual property has increasingly assumed a vital role with the rapid pace of technological, scientific and medical innovation. Intellectual property rights are viewed with increasing importance in many fields of business as the development of any Society directly depends on these Property Rights and its policy framework. Lack of IPR awareness results in the extinction of inventions, risk of infringement, economic loss and decline of an intellectual era in the country.

Categories

Property is broadly divided into two categories – Public property and Private Property. Property is also divided as Tangible property and Intangible Property. Tangible properties are moveable and immoveable property. Intangible properties are intellectual property and reputation of the individual. Intellectual property is again divided into industrial property and literary property. Industrial property is a subset of intellectual property (IP) that includes patents, trademarks, industrial designs and geographical indications. Literary property refers to a specific category within intellectual property, encompassing written works like books, poems, articles and plays, which are protected by copyright laws, essentially giving the author exclusive rights to reproduce, distribute and adapt their creation; it is essentially a subset of intellectual property that focuses solely on literary creations.

History of IPRs globally

The history of IP globally can be traced back to ancient civilizations, with the earliest recognized form of IP protection appearing in ancient Greece around 500 BCE, where the state of Sybaris granted temporary monopolies for culinary inventions. However, the first well-documented patent system emerged in the Venetian Republic in 1474 which is considered a landmark moment in IPR development. Later, key developments included the "Statute of Monopolies" in England (1623) which established the concept of protecting true inventors. But, the Paris Convention (1883) for the Protection of Industrial Property, marked the beginning of international standardization of IPRs.

History of IPRs in India

While there is no formal "intellectual property rights" system in the sense of modern law in pre-Christian India, historical evidence suggests that the concept of protecting knowledge and creative expression, particularly within the Guru-Shishya tradition, was valued and practiced, with practices like marking pottery with unique symbols possibly indicating a form of early trademarking. However, the idea of individual ownership of knowledge was generally considered to be shared freely within communities. During British rule, India adopted several legal frameworks based on British laws, including those related to intellectual property. The first copyright law in India, for example, was the Copyright Act of 1847, which was essentially an extension of the British Copyright Act of 1842. Thus, India's colonial history has significantly influenced its intellectual property (IP) laws. 

After gaining independence in 1947, India began to develop its own legal systems and policies, but the foundation laid during the colonial period continued to shape its approach to intellectual property. The Indian Patent Act of 1970 and the Copyright Act of 1957, for example, were influenced by earlier British laws but were modified to suit India's socio-economic needs and priorities. India's colonial history also influenced its approach to IP in terms of balancing the rights of creators with the needs of the public. The emphasis on access to knowledge and affordable medicines, for example, can be traced back to the colonial experience of dealing with monopolies and restrictive practices.

Laws in India

On the basis of type of invention and creation of human mind and their application, the IPRs are grouped and the laws were made to govern them in India. They are -

Copyright Act, 1957 (last amended in 2012): This Right is granted to the Creator of literary, dramatic, musical, artistic, sound recording, database, software etc by the Copyrights Registrar under the authority of Controller General of Patents, Designs & Trade Marks (CGPDTM), Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), Ministry of Commerce & Industry (MoCI), Govt of India (GoI). It is a non-transferable right. These works do not require renewal registration and the copyright lasts for the life of the author plus 60 years.

Patents Act, 1970 (last amended in 2006): Right is granted for inventive inventions like devices, substances, methods, processes etc that pass through Novelty, Utility and Non-obviousness (NUN) criteria for 20 years by the Patents Registrar under the same authority i.e. CGPDTM and the right is renewable and transferable.

Trade Marks Act, 1999: Right is granted for word, symbol, logo, emblem, name, design, device, sign, stamp, badge, crest, phrase, slogan etc to the owner for 10 years by the Registrar of Trademarks under the same authority i.e. CGPDTM and the right is renewable and transferable to the assignee by the owner.

Geographical Indications of Goods (Regn. & Protection) Act, 1999: It is for agricultural produce, food items, handicrafts, musical instruments, wines and beverages, industrial products etc. It is granted for 10 years by the same authority i.e. CGPDTM and renewable. A registered GI is not transferable; it cannot be assigned, licensed, mortgaged, or transferred in any way, as it is considered a collective right belonging to the producers of a specific geographical area, not an individual entity.

Industrial Designs Act, 2000: Right is given for consumer electrical and electronics, automobiles, furniture, household appliances, packaging, kitchenware etc. It is granted for 10 years by the Registrar of Industrial Designs under the same authority i.e. CGPDTM. This is renewable and transferable.

Semiconductor Integrated Circuits Layout-Design Act, 2000: Semi-Conductor Integrated Circuits Layout-Design Registry (SICLDR) under the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MEIT) is the authority that grants licence to the applicant for 10 years for their chips, transistors, integrated circuits etc. It is renewable and transferable.

Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers’ Rights Act, 2001: Ownership is granted to plant breeders if the plant varieties meet the Distinctiveness Uniformity & Stability (DUS) criteria and is also novel. Protection of farmers' rights act recognizes the rights of farmers who contribute to the conservation, improvement and availability of plant genetic resources. The proprietary ownerships are granted for 9 years for trees and vines and 6 years for other crops by the PPVFR Authority under the Department of Agriculture & Cooperation (DoAC) of Govt of India (GoI). They are renewable and transferable/assignable.

Protection of Biological Diversity Act, 2002: aims to protect biodiversity and ensure sustainable use of biological resources through traditional knowledge, practices and innovations. National Biodiversity Authority (NBD) under Ministry of Environment, Forests & Climate Change (MoEFC), Govt of India (GoI) regulates this. It protects local knowledge.

Trade Secrets Bill, 2024: Trade secrets are so far governed by the Common Law Principles (known as case laws rather than statutes), Indian Contracts Act, 1872 and Indian Penal Code 1860). The 22nd Law Commission of India has recommended a Trade Secrets Bill, 2024 to protect trade secrets.

Here, IPRs of 6 areas namely Copyrights, Patents, Trade Marks, GIs, Industrial Designs and Trade Secrets only are discussed.

1. Copyright

A copyright is a legal protection granted to creators of original works like books, music, movies, or software, essentially giving them the exclusive right to reproduce, distribute, and adapt their creation without unauthorized use by others; it ensures that the author can control how their work is utilized and can be enforced through legal action if someone infringes on those rights by copying or distributing their work without permission.

Criteria for obtaining

Copyright protection is automatic in most countries including India for original works of authorship, including:

Originality: The work must be the author's own creation and not a copy of someone else's work

Fixation: The work must be fixed in a tangible medium of expression, such as a written manuscript, a recording, or a computer file.

Copyright registration is not mandatory, but it is good to register it as it provides prima-facie evidence about the ownership.

Fair Use in Copyright

The "fair use" doctrine allows limited use of copyrighted material without the permission of the copyright holder for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, education, teaching, scholarship, and research. It is a complex legal doctrine that requires balancing the interests of the copyright holder with the public interest in access to information.

First-Sale and Work-for-Hire in Copyright

The first sale doctrine allows the owner of a copyrighted work to sell or transfer ownership of a particular copy of the work. Once the copy is sold, the copyright holder loses control over further distribution of that specific copy.

Under the work for hire doctrine, copyright ownership of a work created by an employee within the scope of their employment belongs to the employer. Similarly, copyright ownership of a work created by an independent contractor belongs to the employer if it was commissioned specifically for that purpose.

Copyright infringement and Plagiarism

Copyright infringement is a legal violation, while plagiarism is an ethical and academic issue. Copyright infringement occurs when someone uses or exploits protected intellectual property without permission, while plagiarism is the act of using someone else's work without proper attribution.

Defenses to copyright infringement

Common defenses to copyright infringement are -

1. Fair use: The use of copyrighted material is allowed for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research
2. Public domain: The work is no longer protected by copyright and is freely available to the public.
3. Independent creation: The defendant created the work independently without copying from the copyrighted work.
4. License: The defendant had a valid license from the copyright holder to use the work.

2. Patent

A patent is the granting of a property right by a sovereign authority to an inventor for inventions. This grant provides the inventor exclusive rights to the patented process, design, or invention for a designated period in exchange for a comprehensive disclosure of the invention. They are a form of incorporeal right. Granted for 20 years and after that it becomes “Off Patent” and open to the general public. Patent is granted for products and process as well.

NUN in Patent law

In patent law, "NUN" refers to the three key criteria that an invention must meet to be considered patentable. It is Novelty, Utility, and Non-obviousness. Essentially, it means the invention must be new, have a useful purpose and not be readily apparent to someone skilled in the field.

1. The novelty requirement means that the invention must be new and not previously disclosed to the public. It must not be anticipated by prior art.
2. The utility requirement means that the invention must have a practical use or function. It must be capable of producing a useful, concrete and tangible result.
3. The non-obviousness requirement means that the invention must not be obvious to someone skilled in the relevant field. It must be more than just an obvious modification or combination of existing technology.

Patent types

The main types of patents are

1. Utility patents: Protect new and useful processes, machines, manufactures, compositions of matter and improvements thereof.
2. Design patents: Protect the ornamental design of an article of manufacture.
3. Plant patents: Protect new and distinct, asexually reproduced plants.

Ever greening in patent law

Ever greening is a strategy used by companies to extend the life of their patents and maintain their commercial exclusivity. It involves making minor changes to an existing product and claiming it as a new invention. The goal is to prevent competitors from bypassing the original patent and creating a similar product. For example, efficiency in medicine means therapeutic efficiency. 

Process for a patent

Obtaining a patent typically involves three steps:

1. File a patent application: The application must describe the invention in detail and include drawings or diagrams
2. Examination: The patent office examines the application to determine whether the invention meets patentability criteria, such as novelty, non-obviousness and utility (NUN).
3. Grant: If the patent office approves the application, a patent is granted, which gives the inventor exclusive rights to the invention for a specific period.

Patent and Copyright

Patents protect inventions, which are functional creations. Copyrights protect original works of authorship, which are creative expressions. A patent grants exclusive rights to manufacture, use and sell the invention, while a copyright grants exclusive rights to reproduce, distribute and display the work.

Role of a patent attorney

Patent attorneys are legal professionals who specialize in patent law. They advise clients on patent strategy, draft patent applications, prosecute patent applications before the patent office, and handle patent litigation.

3. Trademark

The purpose of a trademark is to identify and distinguish the goods or services of one party from those of others. It helps consumers identify the source of the products and prevents others from using similar marks that could cause confusion.

Madrid Agreement 

Madrid Agreement was concluded in 1891. This agreement has been revised several times, most recently in 1979. This is an international treaty that allows trademark owners to register their marks in multiple countries through a single application. It simplifies the process of obtaining trademark protection in different jurisdictions.

Trademark and Service mark

A trademark identifies and distinguishes the source of a product, a service mark identifies the source of a service, a certification mark signifies that a product meets certain quality standards set by a certifying body, and a collective mark is used by a group of businesses to indicate membership in that group. Class 1 to 34 are for goods and 35 to 45 are for services. For example -

1. Trademark: The "Tata" logo on a car, signifying that it is manufactured by Tata Motors. Maruthi, Mahindra, Philip, Bajaj etc had their own logos.
2. Service Mark: The "MakeMyTrip" logo for online travel booking services. Same is the case with Air India, Indigo etc airline services.
3. Certification Mark: The "ISI" mark on electrical appliances, signifying that it meets Indian Standard Institute quality standards. BIS for Gold, AgMark for Agrl produce, FSAAI for food products etc
4. Collective Mark: The "CII" (Confederation of Indian Industry) logo used by member companies to indicate their affiliation with the organization. Similarly, ICAI (Institute of Chartered Accountants of India), IMA (Indian Medical Association) etc

Prior use in Trademark

"Prior use" is primarily applicable in trademark law; specifically, it refers to the legal concept where a person who has been using a trademark before another party registers it can still claim rights to that mark, even if they have not formally registered it themselves, thus protecting their earlier usage against a later registrant.

Advantages of a TM

The advantages of registering a trademark could be -

1. Exclusive rights: Registration gives the owner exclusive rights to use the mark nationwide.
2. Presumption of validity: A registered trademark is presumed to be valid, which can make it easier to enforce.
3. State protection: A registered trademark is protected under state law, providing a stronger legal basis for enforcement.
4. Increased brand recognition: Registration can help build brand awareness and recognition.

Common considerations in choosing a trademark

Considerations in choosing a trademark include:

1. Distinctiveness: The mark should be distinctive and easily recognizable.
2. Availability: The mark should not be already registered or in use by another company.
3. Relevance: The mark should be relevant to the goods or services being identified.
4. Memorable: The mark should be memorable and easy to pronounce.
5. Legal protection: The mark should be legally protectable.

Types of TMs

The main types of trademarks include:

1. Standard character marks: Words, letters, and numbers used as trademarks.
2. Design marks: Logos, symbols, and other graphic elements used as trademarks.
3. Sound marks: Distinctive sounds used as trademarks.
4. Color marks: Specific colors used as trademarks.
5. 3D marks: Three-dimensional shapes of products or packaging used as trademarks.

"Likelihood of Confusion" and “Deceptive Similarity” in TMs

The likelihood of confusion standard is a key factor in trademark infringement cases. It determines whether the use of a mark by one party is likely to confuse consumers as to the source of the goods or services.

Deceptive similarity refers to the practice of creating trademarks that closely resemble existing, well-known trademarks. These counterfeits are created with the intention of fooling customers into thinking that they are purchasing goods or services from a reputable company when, in reality, this is not the case.

TM Infringement

Infringement occurs when someone uses or exploits protected intellectual property without the permission of the rights holder. For example, using a trademark without authorization, copying a copyrighted work, or making and selling a product that violates a patent.

Defenses to TM infringement

Common defenses to trademark infringement include:

1. No likelihood of confusion: The defendant's use of the mark is unlikely to cause confusion among consumers.
2. Fair use: The defendant's use of the mark is for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research.
3. Abandonment: The plaintiff has abandoned their trademark rights through non-use or by allowing others to use the mark without objection.
4. Laches: The plaintiff has delayed in bringing the infringement claim, which has prejudiced the defendant.

4. Geographical Indication

Geographical Indications of Goods are defined as that aspect of industrial property which refer to the geographical indication referring to a country or to a place situated therein as being the country or place of origin of that product. Typically, such a name conveys an assurance of quality and distinctiveness which is essentially attributable to the fact of its origin in that defined geographical locality, region or country. Under Articles 1 (2) and 10 of the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, geographical indications are covered as an element of IPRs. They are also covered under Articles 22 to 24 of the Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement, which was part of the Agreements concluding the Uruguay Round of GATT negotiations.

Famous GIs in India

GI is a tag/sign used on products that have a specific geographical origin and possess qualities or a reputation that are due to that origin.

Some famous registered geographical indications in India are - Darjeeling Tea, Pochampalli Ikkat, Kanchi silks, Dharmavaram Handlooms, Muga Silk of Assam, Champa Silks of Chattisgarh, Eathomozhy coconut, Nagpur santra, Navara rice, Palakkadan Matta rice, Basmati rice, Mysore malligai, Kondapalli wooden toys, Srikalahasti kalamkari, Maharashtra Alphonso mangoes, Malabar pepper, Kashimiri Saffron, Kashmiri pashmina shawls, Konoor coffee, Karnataka bidri, Coorg honey etc  

Famous GI litigations in India

1. Tea Board Vs ITC Limited on Tea leaves
2. Tamil Nadu Vs Kerala on Navara Rice
3. LIDCOM Vs LIDCOR on Kolhapuri Chappals
4. TTD vs RS Praveen Raj of Trivandrum on Tirupathi Laddu

5. Industrial designs

Industrial design rights are intellectual property rights that protect the visual appearance of a product. They apply to the shape, color, materials, and other features of a product that make it aesthetically pleasing.  Industrial design rights protect the appearance of a product, but not its technical or functional features. These features can be protected by a patent. Industrial design rights can apply to a wide variety of products, including: Packages and containers, Furnishing and household goods, Lighting equipment, Jewellery, Electronic devices, Textiles. Benefits of industrial design rights include: Preventing others from reproducing a popular design, setting the price without being undercut by competitors. The duration of protection for industrial design rights can vary by country, but is typically at least 10 years. The term can be extended for an additional five years. The Geneva Act (1999) of The Hague Agreement is an international registration system that protects industrial designs globally.

Famous ID disputes India

1. Carlsberg Breweries A/S vs Som Distilleries & Breweries Limited
2. Havells India Limited vs Panasonic Life Solutions India Pvt Ltd
3. Crocs Inc. USA vs Aqualite India Limited and Another
4. Whirlpool Of India Ltd vs Videocon Industries Ltd
5. Micolube India Limited vs Rakesh Kumar Trading as Saurabh
6. M/S Crocs Inc USA vs M/S Bata India Ltd & Others

6. Trade Secrets

A trade secret is confidential information that provides a company with a competitive advantage. It is protected by maintaining secrecy and taking reasonable steps to prevent disclosure. A trade secret in India could include things like the exact recipe for a popular Indian spice blend, the manufacturing process for a specific type of traditional textile, a unique design element in a car model from Tata Motors, or the customer list of a large Indian e-commerce platform, all of which are kept confidential to maintain a competitive edge and are protected through legal means like non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) and contractual obligations; a prominent case example is the "Coca-Cola formula" where the exact recipe is considered a trade secret, and its protection has been upheld in Indian courts through cases like "Gujarat Bottling Company vs. Coca-Cola" where the company's sale to a competitor was deemed a breach of confidentiality.

Examples of trade secrets

Common examples of trade secrets include:

1. Formulas (e.g., Coca-Cola's formula)
2. Customer lists (e.g., a sales team's list of clients)
3. Business plans (e.g., a company's strategic plan)
4. Software algorithms (e.g., a proprietary algorithm used in a software program)

Remedies for infringement

a)      Legal remedies for infringement can include:

1. Injunction: A court order prohibiting the infringer from continuing the infringing activities.
2. Damages: Monetary compensation for the harm caused by the infringement
3. Seizure of infringing goods: Confiscation of counterfeit or infringing products
4. Criminal prosecution: In some cases, infringement can result in criminal charges, especially for willful or repeated violations.

Famous Trade Secret cases in India

1. Coca-Cola Vs Gujarat Bottling Company
2. Tata Motors Vs Fiat India:
3. Dr. Reddy's Laboratories Vs Ramesh Deshpande

Paris Convention in IP law

The Paris Convention, adopted in 1883, applies to industrial property in the widest sense, including patents, trademarks, industrial designs, utility models, service marks, trade names, geographical indications and the repression of unfair competition. This international agreement was the first major step taken to help creators ensure that their intellectual works were protected in other countries. It provides national treatment and priority rights for foreign applicants.

World Trade Organisation

The WTO began life on 1 January 1995, but its trading system is older. Since 1948, the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) had provided the rules for the system of WTO. It plays a crucial role in Intellectual Property Rights through its Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), which sets minimum standards for the protection and enforcement of IPRs across member countries, ensuring a level playing field for intellectual property holders when trading internationally and facilitating global trade in knowledge and creativity; it also provides a forum to resolve trade disputes related to IPRs through its dispute settlement mechanism.

World Intellectual Property Organization

WIPO is a specialized agency of the United Nations that administers treaties concerning intellectual property. It aims to promote the protection of intellectual property worldwide and to facilitate the use of IP for economic and social development. World Intellectual Property Day is celebrated annually on 26th April to raise awareness of intellectual property rights and to educate people on how to safeguard them. It marks the date when the Convention establishing the World Intellectual Property Organization came into force in 1970, essentially signifying the official establishment of WIPO.

TRIPS Agreement

The TRIPS Agreement (Agreement of Trade Related aspects of Intellectual Property Rights) is an agreement between all the members of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) was adopted on 15th April 1994 and went into effect on 1st January 1995. WTO has 164 member nations plus 24 observer governments. This agreement is considered the most comprehensive multilateral agreement on Intellectual Properties. It is an international agreement that sets minimum standards for the protection of intellectual property rights in the context of international trade.

IPR Policy in India

India's National Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Policy was adopted in 2016 to promote the creation, commercialization and protection of IPRs. It encompasses all IPRs into a single vision document setting in place an institutional mechanism for implementation, monitoring and review of laws. The policy's goals include:

1. Raising awareness: Educating the public about the economic, social, and cultural benefits of IPRs
2. Encouraging IPR generation: Stimulating the creation and commercialization of IPRs
3. Modernizing IPR administration: Strengthening the service-oriented administration of IPRs
4. Enforcing IPRs: Improving the enforcement and adjudicatory mechanisms for combating IPR infringements
5. Promoting traditional knowledge: Promoting India's rich legacy of traditional knowledge

Ethical considerations

Ethical aspects in intellectual property legal frame work can include;

1. Balance between creator rights and public access: Striking a balance between protecting the rights of creators and ensuring public access to information and knowledge.
2. Fair use of copyrighted material: Ensuring that the fair use doctrine is not abused to circumvent copyright protection.
3. Patent trolling: Discouraging the use of patents for abusive or extortionate purposes.
4. Access to essential medicines: Ensuring that patents on life-saving medications do not prevent access to affordable healthcare

Mistakes in protection of IPs

Common mistakes that businesses make with regard to intellectual property protection include

1. Failing to identify and protect valuable intellectual property: Many businesses fail to recognize the importance of protecting their intellectual property and may not take steps to secure their right
2. Not seeking legal advice: Businesses may attempt to handle intellectual property matters themselves, which can lead to costly mistakes
3. Delaying in filing for protection: Waiting too long to file for patent, trademark, or copyright protection can result in the loss of valuable rights.
4. Not enforcing their rights: Businesses may fail to take action against infringers, which can weaken their intellectual property position.
5. Disclosing intellectual property prematurely: Revealing intellectual property too early, such as through public presentations or online publications, can jeopardize patent protection.

Career opportunities

In this regime the career opportunities are -

1. Patent attorney: Advising clients on patent strategy, drafting patent applications, prosecuting patent applications and handling patent litigation.
2. Trademark attorney: Advising clients on trademark strategy, registering trademarks, enforcing trademark rights and handling trademark litigation.
3. Copyright attorney: Advising clients on copyright strategy, registering copyrights, enforcing copyright rights and handling copyright litigation.
4. Intellectual property lawyer: Providing general legal advice and services related to intellectual property, including licensing, assignment and commercialization
5. Intellectual property paralegal: Assisting intellectual property attorneys with legal research, document preparation and other tasks.
6. Intellectual property manager: Managing an organization's intellectual property portfolio, including patents, trademarks and copyrights.

Skills for a career

Key skills for a successful career in intellectual property law include:

1. Strong analytical and problem-solving skills: To understand complex legal issues and develop effective strategies.
2. Excellent written and verbal communication skills: To draft legal documents, communicate effectively with clients, and present arguments in court.
3. Attention to detail: To ensure accuracy in legal research, document preparation, and patent applications.
4. Ability to work independently and as part of a team: To manage projects, collaborate with colleagues, and work effectively in a fast-paced environment.
5. Knowledge of intellectual property law: To understand the legal framework governing patents, trademarks, and copyrights.
6. Technical aptitude: To understand the technical aspects of inventions and technologies.

Challenges in 21^st Century

Challenges facing intellectual property statutes in the 21st century include:

1. Rapid technological advancements: The rapid pace of innovation and technological change raises new challenges for intellectual property protection.
2. Globalization: The rise of global trade and the internet has made it more difficult to enforce intellectual property rights across borders.
3. Digital piracy: The ease of copying and sharing digital content has led to widespread piracy and infringement.
4. Patent trolls: Patent trolls assert patent rights for the purpose of extracting licensing fees or settlements, which can stifle innovation.
5. Access to essential medicines: Patents on life-saving medications can prevent access to affordable healthcare, particularly in developing countries.

Important IP infringement cases

Examples of intellectual property infringement cases that have made headlines in recent years include:

1. Apple vs. Samsung: A series of high-profile patent infringement lawsuits over smartphone designs and features.
2. Oracle vs. Google: A long-running lawsuit over Google's use of Java APIs in Android.
3. Warner Bros. vs. Right Haven: A case involving copyright trolling and the use of automated copyright enforcement systems.
4. Taylor Swift vs. Scooter Braun: A dispute over the ownership of Taylor Swift's music catalogue.
5. The Pirate Bay: A notorious file-sharing website that has been repeatedly targeted for copyright infringement.

In India, in recent years, some prominent intellectual property infringement cases include: "Flipkart vs. Marc Enterprises," "Metro Shoes vs. Flipkart," "GrabOn vs. GrabOnRent," "MakeMyTrip vs. copycat companies," and "PolicyBazaar vs. Acko," where companies have taken legal action against businesses allegedly copying their brand names, designs, or services, highlighting the growing concern around intellectual property protection in the Indian start-up ecosystem.

Future of IP law

The future of intellectual property law is likely to be shaped by several trends, like -

1. Increased focus on digital assets: Intellectual property law will need to adapt to protect new forms of digital assets, such as software, databases, and online content.
2. Artificial intelligence and machine learning: The development of AI and machine learning raises questions about ownership and protection of intellectual property created by these technologies.
3. Open innovation and collaborative creativity: The rise of open innovation and collaborative creativity models will require new approaches to intellectual property protection and licensing.
4. Data privacy: The increasing importance of data privacy will intersect with intellectual property law, particularly in areas such as trade secrets and personal data.

Strategies for competitive advantage

Successful intellectual property strategies that have helped companies to achieve competitive advantage can be -

1. Patenting key innovations: Companies like Apple and Google have aggressively patented their technology, giving them control over key aspects of their products and services
2. Building strong brands: Companies like Nike and Coca-Cola have invested heavily in building strong trademarks, which have become synonymous with their products.
3. Protecting trade secrets: Companies like KFC and WD-40 have carefully guarded their secret formulas, giving them a competitive edge.
4. Licensing intellectual property: Companies like Microsoft and Qualcomm license their technologies to other companies, generating significant revenue and expanding their market reach.

Resources for learning

Important resources for learning about intellectual property law include:

1. Books and articles: Many books and articles provide comprehensive overviews of intellectual property law.
2. Online resources: Websites of the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks, Registrars of Patents, Copyrights and Trade Marks, Ministry of Commerce and Industry of GOI, the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), The World Trade Organisation provide valuable information and resources.
3. Law colleges: Many law school and colleges offer courses and programs in intellectual property law
4. Professional organizations: Professional organizations offer networking opportunities, educational resources, and industry updates.

Staying updated

Businesses can stay updated on developments in intellectual property law by:

1. Subscribing to legal publications: Many publications specialize in intellectual property law.
2. Attending industry events: Professional organizations host conferences, seminars, and workshops on intellectual property law.
3. Following legal blogs and websites: Many blogs and websites provide commentary and analysis on intellectual property law developments.
4. Networking with professionals: Networking with lawyers, patent agents, and other professionals in the field can provide insights into current trends and issues.

IPs & Start-ups

Tips for protecting intellectual property in a start-up include:

1. Seek legal advice early: Consult with an intellectual property lawyer to develop a comprehensive IP strategy.
2. Identify and document your intellectual property: Determine what intellectual property is valuable to your business and create documentation to prove ownership.
3. File for patent, trademark, or copyright protection: Protect your valuable intellectual property through appropriate legal mechanisms.
4. Maintain confidentiality: Take steps to keep your intellectual property confidential, such as using non-disclosure agreements.
5. Educate employees: Train employees on the importance of intellectual property protection and proper handling of confidential information.
6. Monitor for infringement: Regularly search for instances of potential infringement and take action to protect your rights.

Arguments

Arguments for strong intellectual property protection are 

1. Incentives for innovation: Strong intellectual property rights encourage innovation by providing creators with exclusive rights to exploit their creations.
2. Investment and economic growth: Intellectual property protection allows companies to commercialize their inventions and create jobs, contributing to economic growth.
3. Fair return for creators: Creators deserve to be rewarded for their efforts and to benefit from the value of their creations.

Arguments against strong intellectual property protection are 

1. Barriers to entry: Strong intellectual property rights can create barriers to entry for new companies, stifling competition.
2. Limits on access to knowledge: Strong intellectual property protection can limit access to knowledge and innovation, particularly in fields such as medicine and technology
3. Patent trolling: Patent trolls exploit intellectual property rights for abusive purposes, harming innovation and economic growth.

IP law & social good

Intellectual property law can contribute to social good by:

1. Promoting access to healthcare: By ensuring that essential medicines are affordable and accessible to those who need them.
2. Encouraging the development of new technologies: By providing incentives for innovation in areas such as renewable energy, sustainable agriculture, and disease prevention.
3. Supporting creative industries: By protecting the rights of artists, musicians, and writers, fostering creativity and cultural expression.
4. Combating counterfeiting and piracy: By protecting consumers from harmful or fraudulent products and ensuring fair competition in the marketplace.

Public Interest

Striking a balance between intellectual property rights and the public interest is essential for a functioning society. While protecting intellectual property is important for innovation and economic growth, it is also crucial to ensure that knowledge and technology are accessible to the public. This requires careful consideration of factors such as fair use, open innovation, and public health.

Technology

Technology plays a crucial role in both protecting and infringing intellectual property. Digital Rights Management (DRM) technologies can help to prevent unauthorized copying and distribution of copyrighted content. Forensic techniques can be used to identify infringers and track the distribution of infringing materials. However, technology can also be used to facilitate infringement. For example, peer-to-peer file-sharing networks can be used to distribute copyrighted content without authorization. It is important to use technology responsibly and to stay informed about the latest developments in this area.

The rise of open source software and collaborative innovation presents a challenge to traditional intellectual property models. Open source software is typically licensed under licenses that allow for free use, modification, and distribution. This approach encourages collaboration and innovation, but it can also raise concerns about the protection of proprietary interests. It is important to find ways to reconcile these different models and to ensure that intellectual property law supports both open innovation and the protection of proprietary interests.

IP in the digital age - Challenges

Common issues related to IP are certain infringements. They are -

1. Copyright infringement: The ease of copying and sharing digital content has made copyright infringement a significant problem.
2. Trademark infringement: The use of trademarks in online advertising and e-commerce can lead to infringement issues.
3. Patent infringement: Software and technology innovations are increasingly subject to patent protection, leading to disputes over infringement.
4. Privacy concerns: The collection and use of personal data raise privacy concerns related to intellectual property rights.

Enforcing intellectual property rights in the digital age is a complex challenge. The ease of copying and sharing digital content has made it difficult to prevent infringement. The global nature of the internet makes it difficult to track down infringers and enforce legal remedies. Moreover, the rapid pace of technological change can make it difficult to keep up with new forms of infringement. New approaches and technologies are needed to effectively enforce intellectual property rights in the digital age.

Big data and Machine learning

The rise of big data and machine learning presents both opportunities and challenges for intellectual property law. Data sets themselves can be considered intellectual property, raising issues of ownership, privacy, and access. Machine learning algorithms can generate new creations, leading to questions about ownership and authorship. The legal framework for protecting intellectual property in this context is still evolving, and it is important to stay informed about developments in this area.

Impact of AI on IPs

The rapid development of artificial intelligence (AI) raises complex questions for intellectual property law. AI systems can create new forms of intellectual property, such as algorithms, code, and data. The issue of ownership and protection of these creations is still being debated. It is important to consider how to ensure that AI-generated works are properly attributed and protected, while also promoting innovation and ethical development.

Big data and Machine learning

The rise of big data and machine learning presents both opportunities and challenges for intellectual property law. Data sets themselves can be considered intellectual property, raising issues of ownership, privacy, and access. Machine learning algorithms can generate new creations, leading to questions about ownership and authorship. The legal framework for protecting intellectual property in this context is still evolving, and it is important to stay informed about developments in this area.

Social media impact

Social media has had a significant impact on intellectual property law. It has made it easier for creators to share their work, but it has also made it easier for infringers to copy and distribute copyrighted content. Social media platforms have faced challenges in policing their sites and removing infringing content. The legal framework for protecting intellectual property on social media is still evolving, and it is important to be aware of the relevant laws and policies.

Role of Govt

Governments play a crucial role in protecting intellectual property. They establish the legal framework for intellectual property rights, such as patents, trademarks, and copyrights. They provide mechanisms for registering and enforcing these rights. They also participate in international agreements to harmonize intellectual property laws across different jurisdictions. It is important for governments to strike a balance between protecting intellectual property and promoting innovation, access to knowledge, and economic growth.

Development tool

Intellectual property can be a valuable tool for economic development. It can help countries to attract foreign investment, develop new industries, and create jobs. However, it is important to ensure that intellectual property rights are balanced with other development objectives, such as access to affordable healthcare, education, and technology. Best example is production of Corona vaccine where European Union and Germany opposed for manufacture of vaccine without a licence from the big pharma companies of the World. Biden too made an election promise to free the restriction. It is also important to address issues such as patent trolling and the misuse of intellectual property rights to stifle competition.

Intellectual property can play a significant role in promoting sustainable development. It can incentivize innovation in areas such as renewable energy, clean technologies, and sustainable agriculture. It can also be used to protect traditional knowledge and cultural heritage, which are crucial for sustainable development. However, it is important to ensure that intellectual property rights are not used to stifle access to essential technologies or knowledge, particularly in developing countries.

Common man and Economy

The main advantage of intellectual property rights (IPRs) is to encourage and protect the creation, distribution, and offering of new goods and services that are based on the development and use of inventions, trademarks, designs, creative works, and other intangible assets.

These rights contribute to a country's economy by encouraging innovation and creativity, attracting investment, promoting technological development, and enabling businesses to capitalize on their unique ideas, ultimately leading to economic growth, particularly in knowledge-based industries; strong IPR protection incentivizes individuals and companies to invest in research and development, knowing they can reap the benefits of their creations through exclusive rights.

Global economy

Intellectual property plays a crucial role in the global economy, driving innovation, trade, and economic growth. It enables companies to create and commercialize new products and services, generate revenue, and create jobs. However, it is important to ensure that intellectual property rights are balanced with other societal interests, such as access to knowledge and public health.

Human rights

The relationship between IP and Human Rights is complex and multifaceted. While intellectual property rights can be seen as a form of property right, they can also have a significant impact on the enjoyment of other human rights, such as the right to health, the right to education, and the right to freedom of expression. It is important to ensure that intellectual property law is implemented in a way that respects human rights and promotes social justice.

IP registration stats in India

According to Statista, during the financial year 2024, India registered over 38,000 copyrights, marking a record number of new copyright registrations issued by the country's Copyright Office. According to the latest data available, as of June 2024, India has registered a total of 643 Geographical Indications (GI) Tags, while the Patent Office granted 1,03,057 patents in the FY 2023-24. Similarly, around 2,80,000 industrial trademarks were registered in India during the 2024 financial year. This data indicates a significant growth in seeking protection for the IPRs when compared to pre economic reforms period i.e. before 1991.

Public Relations and IPRs

Intellectual property (IP) management is closely tied to the Public Relations (PR) profession because PR professionals often need to communicate and protect a company's brand identity, which is heavily reliant on its intellectual property like trademarks, copyrights and patents; ensuring accurate and responsible messaging while safeguarding against potential IP infringement is an important aspect of effective PR strategy. 

Key connections between Intellectual Property management and Public Relations are:

1. Brand protection: PR plays a crucial role in managing a company's brand image, which is often built around its intellectual property. This includes ensuring that the brand is accurately represented in public communications and taking action against any unauthorized use of trademarks or logos. 
2. Reputation management: If a company's IP is infringed upon, it can damage their reputation, which PR professionals must manage through strategic communication.
3. Communication strategy: When launching new products or services that involve intellectual property, PR professionals need to develop communication strategies that effectively highlight the unique features and value proposition while protecting sensitive information.
4. Legal compliance: PR practitioners need to be aware of IP laws and regulations to ensure that their communication strategies do not violate any copyright or trademark rules.
5. Media relations: When managing media inquiries about a company's intellectual property, PR professionals must carefully craft messages that accurately represent the company's position while avoiding any potential legal issues. 

And IP management impacts PR activities in the areas of 

1. Press releases: When announcing new products, PR professionals need to carefully describe the features and benefits without inadvertently disclosing confidential information protected by patents or trade secrets.
2. Social media management: Monitoring social media for potential misuse of a company's trademarks or copyrighted content and taking appropriate action if necessary.
3. Crisis communication: If a company faces an IP infringement lawsuit, PR professionals must develop a communication plan to address the situation with transparency and accuracy. 

Effective Intellectual Property management is critical for Public Relations professionals to protect an Organisation's reputation and ensure that their communication strategies align with legal requirements regarding Intellectual Property Rights. 

https://youtube.com/live/KFPJ2EU6tuU Follow this link to watch my Live Phone-in Program on IPRs on 30-12-2024 at Doordarshan Kendra, Hyderabad 

Y Babji, Advocate & IPR Attorney

l